The R&D Tax Credit for Architects and Engineers
Introduction
In the most recent year for which data is available, engineering and architecture firms claimed over $1 Billion in R&D Tax Credits.
This tremendous incentive is a dollar-for-dollar federal Credit that can be claimed yearly and used to offset tax liability. The Credit allows firms to hire new employees, expand their technologies, and finance other business objectives. Some states have their own versions of the Credit, further boosting the possible benefit.
Many A/E firms simply aren’t aware that their day-to-day activities may qualify. In 2018, an AIA firm survey revealed that only 28% of eligible firms applied for and claimed this tax credit.
If you own an A/E firm, or advise someone who does, you should know how to tap into this Credit.
Why is A/E Such a Good Fit for the R&D Tax Credit?
Engineers and architects are constantly designing, evaluating, and refining. This evolving cycle of innovation is precisely what the R&D Credit is intended to reward.
It doesn’t really matter what’s being designed – a sanitary sewer system, a heat exchanger, a new high-rise. Creating and executing a new design – or improving an existing one – unlocks R&D Tax Credit savings.
Any firm may qualify for the Credit if they are creating or improving products – including designs – or processes.
How Can A/E Qualify for R&D? (4 Part)
The R&D Tax Credit is an activities-based Credit, and most A/E firms qualify just by performing their routine activities. If you develop or improve a product (design) or process, you likely perform Qualifying Research Activities (QRAs).
To officially be considered a QRA, your activity must pass the IRS’ Four-Part Test. This is generally a very easy task for an A/E firm. Let’s take a look at how each A/E passes each part of the Test, and check them off as we examine each one:
PART I: New or Improved Business Component:
The activity must be related to developing or improving the functionality, quality, reliability, or performance of a business component.
- The “business component” for most architects and engineers is the design itself, be it physical or digital.
There was some confusion about whether design could really be considered a “product,” and this ambiguity led to hesitation on the part of some A/E firms. However, in May of 2023, Harper v. Commissioner confirmed that even if design can’t be considered a tangible “product,” it can certainly be considered a “process” or “invention,” and as such is indeed a business component. The Harper decision allows A/E firms to confidently move forward in claiming the R&D Tax Credit. - The design doesn’t need to be a brand-new, revolutionary creation – though it could be. The design could simply be an improved version of an older model, which is more functional, reliable, sustainable, etc.
- The “business component” could also be a new or improved engineering process, or product.In any case — CHECK.
PART II: Elimination of Uncertainty:
The activity must be undertaken for the purpose of eliminating some uncertainty:
- Can I make a brand-new business component (design)?
- What will it look like? How can I make it?
- Can I improve an old business component (design)?
- Can I improve the process by which the business component (design) is made?
Another easy CHECK – these are the questions architects and engineers ask themselves every day.
PART III: Process of Experimentation:
- The activity must involve some kind of experimentation designed to resolve the uncertainty, which may include:
- Evaluation of Alternatives
- 3D Modeling or Simulations
- Systematic Trial and Error
A third CHECK – in a very real sense, the entire iterative design process is a process of experimentation.
PART IV: Technological in nature:
The activity must be based on a hard science – engineering, architecture, physics, etc.
The final CHECK – that’s a 100% on this test.
Which A/E Activities Qualify? (QRAs)
Clearly, architects and engineers are going to ace the four-part test. So which specific activities actually qualify? Let’s take a closer look.
Every type of A/E involves a myriad of activities that likely qualify. If the activity involves an iterative design process and evaluation of alternatives, it’s probably a Qualified Research Activity (QRA.) The table below includes many common QRAs, sorted by type:
What Costs Can A/E Firms Claim Towards the R&D Credit? (QREs)
Qualified Research Expenses (QREs) are expenses related to QRAs. QREs are the expenses that can qualify for the Credit, and they fall into 4 categories:
- Employee Wages
- Third-Party Contractor Payments
- Cloud Hosting Expenses
- Supplies and Materials
Let’s look at the most common QREs for A/E firms more closely:
Employee Wages
Employee wages are a major QRE. The following job titles are illustrative of the types of positions eligible:
How Can A/E Claim the R&D Credit?
A/E firms can claim the R&D Credit by filing IRS Form 6765, Credit for Increasing Research Activities. Taxpayers must provide “sufficient documentation” to support the amount of QREs they are claiming.
The IRS does not specify what constitutes “sufficient documentation,” and indeed the nature of the documentation will vary by type of firm. In general, the more documentation you can retain and provide as needed, the better. Here are some examples of helpful documentation:
- Payroll information for employees directly involved in R&D and for employees or managers supervising them (many firms have time-tracking software that is also helpful)
- General ledger or job costing reports indicating which costs were related to R&D activities
- Copies of contracts and invoices paid to third-party contractors
- General documents that demonstrate the research process and progress: design revisions, test results, blueprints, drawings, emails, presentations, meeting minutes, etc.
- Iterative modeling software that tracks changes, revisions and clashes
Credible employee testimony is also helpful in substantiating the R&D Tax Credit claim, especially in conjunction with documentation.
It’s important to note that you can claim portions of a project. If one small component of a building includes qualified activities, you can claim the time spent on that part.
There is an additional documentation requirement established by Memorandum Number 20214101F, “Minimum Requirements for an R&D Claim.” This 2021 Memorandum states that for each project, the claimant must identify all business components, and for each one:
- Identify all research activities performed;
- Identify all individuals who performed each research activity; and
- Identify all the information each individual sought to discover.
In June of 2024, the IRS waived the requirement to provide the information referenced in #2 and #3. However, in the event that a claim is selected for subsequent examination, the IRS may request that information.
In short, you still need to be able to demonstrate who worked on what, when, why, and how, although you may not be called upon to “show your work.”
It’s crucial to select an R&D Provider who understands the documentation requirements for a claim to be successful.
How Large Might the R&D Credit Be for A/E?
The amount of the Credit depends on the value of the QREs, not on company size or overall revenue. The more a company spends to innovate, the more they can potentially save, regardless of company size or scope.
The R&D Tax Credit offers up to 10 cents in benefit for every qualifying dollar identified in a study. Not everyone receives the full 10 cents for every dollar spent, but a good average often used in estimates is 7.9 cents for every dollar. If you have $1M in QREs, you could receive about $79K in Credit, and potentially up to a maximum of $100K.
And that’s only the Federal Credit. If there is a state version of the Credit the benefit could be significantly more, and even doubled in states like California.
Let’s consider an example:
- Mechanical Engineering firm ME is located in Southern California.
- They specialize in design-build and plan/spec. solutions for a variety of commercial property types, with an emphasis on energy-efficient HVAC systems.
- In TY 2024, Firm ME only had one QRE – wages. ME’s qualified wages were $4,544,284.
- This translated to a $239,320 Net Federal Credit and a $310,693 Net State California Credit, for a total Net Credit of $550,013.
This $550K isn’t a deduction that decreases taxable income. It’s a Credit, so it directly reduces the amount of tax that must be paid by $550K.
If Firm ME continues to meet eligibility requirements, it can rely on a $550K Credit annually.
Eligible companies can also look back to prior year returns – usually the last three tax years — to see if they qualified for the Credit in those years as well. In 2024, Firm ME could claim the current year Credit, plus the Credit from 2023, 2022, and 2021, for a whopping $2.2M first year Credit.
And if – in some future year – Firm ME earns a Credit that exceeds its tax liability for that year, the excess Credit can be carried forward for up to 20 years.
What about Small or Start-Up Architecture Firms?
The Payroll R&D Tax Credit is a modified version of the Federal R&D Tax Credit, created specifically for small businesses that do not yet have income tax liability. Created through the PATH Act of 2015, the Payroll R&D Tax Credit permits “Qualified Small Businesses” (QSBs) to claim up to $500,000 annually for tax years beginning after December 31, 2022. QSBs can use that credit to offset the 6.2% employer portion of the Social Security payroll tax under the Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) as well as the 1.45% employer portion of the Medicare payroll tax liability ($250,000 towards each).
(For tax years prior to December 31, 2022, the maximum claim is $250,000 and the credit only applies to the social security tax.)
The Payroll R&D Tax Credit can be taken for up to 5 years, resulting in a potential total credit of $2.5M to apply against payroll taxes. This is a huge boon to start-ups and smaller firms because the Payroll R&D Tax Credit can free up crucial capital needed to grow.
To be considered a “Qualified Small Business,” you must:
- Have less than $5M in gross receipts for the year in which you wish to claim the credit; and
- Never have had gross receipts five years prior to the claim year
Should I Be Concerned about Sec. 174 Amortization?
You might have heard about recent legislative changes that may impact your return. An important change has taken effect, and it involves Section 174 Expenses.
Section 174 Expenses are known as Research and Experimentation, or R&E Expenses. They include Direct Research Expenses that qualify for the R&D Tax Credit, and Indirect Research Expenses that are generally more incidental costs.
The major change is that Sec. 174 Expenses incurred in Tax Year 2022 and beyond can no longer be immediately deducted. They must be amortized over 5 years. The impact of this is primarily a timing issue.
By amortizing the deduction over 5 years, taxpayers will see a higher net taxable income initially. Generally, taxpayers will pay more taxes in year 1 and year 2, but not more overall. In fact, most taxpayers will “break even” by year 3 and pay little to no tax in that year and beyond. Smaller firms and start-ups will likely feel the impact of the increased tax liability more deeply, even if it is only short-term.
However, this is not a reason to avoid claiming the R&D Tax Credit:
- The R&D Tax Credit will actually help mitigate the effects of mandatory amortization
- Skipping a year of the R&D Tax Credit won’t let you “skip” Sec. 174 amortization. The R&D Tax Credit doesn’t create Sec. 174 Expenses – if you have them, you have them, and they must be amortized whether you claim the R&D Tax Credit or not.
- Plus, if you consistently claimed the R&D Tax Credit and suddenly you don’t, that may attract unwanted IRS attention.
Sec. 174 amortization is an important matter to discuss with your taxation expert, but it’s not a reason to eschew the R&D Tax Credit.
What Should A/E do Next?
If you’re interested in learning more about how you might benefit, you need to consult an R&D Tax Credit provider. Your CPA might have a recommendation, or if you’re evaluating providers yourself, be sure to ask these important questions.
Claiming the Credit requires a strong understanding of the A/E industries and how the tax code applies. Your provider will be combing through your process start to finish, identifying all QRAs and tying QREs to them. It’s important to select an R&D Tax Credit provider with the technical and tax knowledge required to do the job right.
The Capstan team can review your situation in a 15-20 minute call to get a sense of your activities and expenses, and then provide a Credit estimate. Please don’t hesitate to contact us – together we can ensure success by design.
“
The Credit allows firms to hire new employees, expand their technologies, and finance other business objectives.
Recent Articles
Predominant Use Studies: Your Top 10 Questions Answered
Predominant Use Studies: Your Top 10 Questions Answered Utility costs are a significant operating expense for many businesses. But what if part of your utility bill is an expense you shouldn’t be paying at all? In many states, electricity, natural gas, and certain...
Look-Back Cost Segregation Studies for Rental Properties
Look-Back Cost Segregation Studies for Rental PropertiesMany rental property owners file their taxes every year without really thinking about depreciation. The building gets depreciated over decades, and no one asks any questions. The problem? Your property isn't...
Cost Segregation Tax Benefits
Cost Segregation Tax Benefits How a Cost Segregation Study Can Reduce Taxes and Improve Cash Flow Real estate owners often think of a building as one large depreciable asset. For tax purposes, however, a property can contain many different components with different...







